I’ve been wondering this question for a while. Ignoring current events, why is a little bit of inflation desirable?
I do understand that it’s done to “stimulate” the economy so people don’t let their cash rot in a checking account, but isn’t it a zero-sum game? Everybody says that money is not meant to stay where it is, rather, should flow through the economy. But if the economy always needs injections of liquidity because otherwise it fails, isn’t the economy broken?
I feel like there’s something I can’t comprehend about that.
Focus on simplicity rather than details:
Deflation (opposite of inflation) encourages people to put money under the pillow and wait for it to increase in value. If everyone does this the economy stagnates.
Inflation encourages people to spend the money now or invest it. Your spending is someone else’s income and their spending is your income. Investing is you risking your money to have someone else buy something that hopefully makes them more productive.
Too high inflation causes loss of trust in the currency and people start hoarding bricks or something else non perishable and the economy stagnates.
So central banks say that they will manipulate the currency so that the inflation is around say 2% which is low enough for people to trust it but high enough to encourage spending/investing.
So inflation isn’t actually good, it’s an active economy that’s good
Yes, but a healthy economy becomes more active if there is a healthy inflation to provide additional lube. 2% is roughly where inflation offers pretty good lubricant without being a pita
It’s worth calling out that there’s no real justification for that 2% figure. It’s a number that was pulled out of the air by the New Zealand version of the Fed in the late 80s, and it seems to work well, so everyone copied it.
There’s pretty broad consensus among economists that deflation is bad, and that inflation above about 3-4% is bad. Beyond that, we’re literally just guessing.
It’s a number that was pulled out of the air by the New Zealand version of the Fed in the late 80s, and it seems to work well, so everyone copied it.
I think it’s worth pointing out that it’s all part of the neoliberalism fad that originated around that time. There are other ways to run an economy, but this inflation target one works well for neoliberalism because the wealthy own assets which hold their value through inflation. The middle class and below have money, which loses value through inflation. They pay what money they do have largely (directly or eventually) to the wealthy who then use it to buy more assets.
Sorry I may have channelled too much Gary Stevenson there.
It’s not guessing. It’s a pretty specific formula.
I have read that it’s also very hard to break out of deflation so you can’t just try it a little, and the same goes for hyper inflation. A bit like walking the razors edge.
Inflation itself is also good, assuming your salary goes up at the same rate.
If you take out a home loan, then over the 30 years you pay off the house, the mortgage payments make up a smaller and smaller part of your paycheck.
Same for car loans, and student loans.
Basically, inflation encourages smart use of debt.
That’s generally not true in practice though. Nominal interest rates on loans (the rate on paper) will adjust with inflation so the real interest rate (adjusted for inflation) is positive. As others have pointed out, the banks wouldn’t accept a loss just because of high inflation.
But that’s included in the loan if the bank doesn’t want to go bankrupt.
Depending on where you live, mortgages can be either fixed or variable. Canada’s mortgages typically change over time. The US’s mortgages are typically fixed for a specific period.
Don’t focus so much on the actual numbers - this is just an example - the idea is the same regardless of what you plug in.
Let’s say it’s 1996 and you live in a midsize town USA. You borrow $100,000 at 5% APR with a 30 year fixed mortgage. Your monthly payment is $537, with most of that going to interest in the first years, and most of it going to principal in the last few. Aside from insurance and property taxes, that $537 mortgage payment is exactly the same on month 1 as it is on month 360.
Lets say you bought the house in 1996 with a monthly salary of $1,500, and your salary only goes up exactly with inflation, you’d be making about $3,200 in 2026.
So the cost of your mortgage went from about 1/3rd of your salary to about 1/6th of your salary.
Yes, the 5% interest was higher than inflation that averaged 2.6% over that time period, but the actual % of your income that went to owning that home went down over the years.
That changes a BIT if you have a variable rate loan, but only in the sense that if interest rates changes, your home payments change (but the impact is lower as time goes on, because the amount you owe also goes down).
My take was just that banks know this “trick” and prevent it one way or another or they’d go broke.
What trick? It’s just a fact about how debt works.
The bank makes more from the interest than they lose from inflation. If inflation is 2.6% and your debt is 5% then they’re making money. Just because the overall payment becomes a smaller part of your salary doesn’t mean that the bank loses money.
It’s literally just basic math.
Well you won’t game anyone with it is all l’m saying.
so basically inflation is good only if you are one of the wealthy ones. being able to get a job that pays enough so you dont have to live hand to mouth. can even get a loan, pay it off and still have some money left over to maybe live. Also having a job you can trust doesnt kick you off at moments notice is also required to even consider any debt.
Over the long term, wages go up. Over the short term, people get left behind.
There are lots of things that suck for individuals, but are good for the economy as a whole. There are also lots of things that suck for the economy as a whole and are great for a select few.
This is why the bedrock of any sane civilized population is public education. We try to give most individuals the opportunity to learn as much about how our society works as possible to give individuals the best chance at success available.
This is also why the current geopolitical situation was built on decades of undermining public education with homeschooling and “parent choice” initiatives. The USA’s “No Child Left Behind” Act created an entire generation of children ripped out of public schools after decades of defunding public education created such poor conditions that parents were duped into believing dismantling public education was the solution.
Uneducated kids become ignorant, easily manipulated voters. Social media algorithms were specifically engineered to exploit this mechanism.
Just want to point put the whole “Deflation makes people not want to spend” thing is bullshit conjured up by a wealthy economist.
In reality the inverse happens - deflation makes the general population spend and inflation makes people save. This is because if you’re expecting things to get expensive, you stop spending on things you might want so you can have money for emergencies and things you might need. This isn’t even theory - you can just look at historical spending patterns.
Inflation primarily benefits the wealthy, because hoarding billions is pointless under deflation.
This songs like it makes sense, but a reference would be very useful
https://360library.com/economics/deflation/common-misconceptions-about.html
This lists a couple of “recent” historical examples you can verify.
And here’s a more detailed analysis:
I have read that it’s also very hard to break out of deflation so you can’t just try it a little, and the same goes for hyper inflation. A bit like walking the razors edge. What’s your thoughts on that?
It’s pretty easy to stop minor deflation - just print more money. You might have also heard why that’s usually bad - because it causes inflation. But in this case, if for some reason you want to limit or reverse it, printing is just one way. Others are by increasing exports and imports by decreasing / increasing taxes, raising interest rates on low, increasing taxes in general.
Of course, the difference is these measures strengthen a country, unlike control measures that deal with inflation. Even the first one is less harmful these days thanks to a very global economy and modern logistics, since spreading your currency has soft power benefits (it’s why the USA did so).
Controlling inflation on the other hand is more detrimental to a country, since the methods usually affect infrastructure (reducing taxes) or global trade (restricting imports to increase local spending). You can also print less money but that increases poverty.
Hence all the recessions in recent history.
Could someone for once please explain what you guys actually mean when you say the wealthy are hoarding money? I don’t think I’ve ever gotten a straight answer to this.
Considering inflation causes money to lose value over time you won’t remain wealthy if you hoard it. What rich people have a lot of is assets that produce money, usually stocks and bonds.
Note: I said hoarding billions - I didn’t say they’re hoarding it in literal cash. They’re hoarding it in value.
Inflation is beneficial if you have billions in value because what you can earn from interest rates and valuations (especially when you can tug at the strings of the stock market) alone will exceed what the inflation rate will be (barring economic collapse where there’s runaway inflation, like the Weimar Republic or Argentina).
This means that your purchasing power goes up since the general population’s and smaller business’ purchasing power goes down, since you can easily outpace inflation far greater than they can. This allows you to hoard more wealth by making it easier to buy up other companies or stocks - and the more you own, the easier it is to ensure that you control the general population’s wages or the growth of competitors and therefore increase your wealth further by staying even further ahead of inflation. If you’re an American even remotely paying attention to things, you might realize this cycle sounds familiar.
This eventually hurts the overall economy if never stopped of course (lack of general active cash flow), because eventually things become too unaffordable for the general population and they can only take so much debt… But if you and your cohorts keep at it, thanks to how the fiat system works, it’s fine. Because you’ll own so much of everything and have so much value hoarded that it doesn’t matter that inflation has crashed everything and your currency has lost significant global power, since you’ll be able to buy up anything else left that you don’t own (Btw, this isn’t hypothetical - this is how Putin and his cronies gained what they had, at the expense of a whole country). From there you and the oligarchs can basically run the government.
And that’s the big picture most people miss - it’s not about the money, it’s about power.
They’re hoarding it in value.
This is what I’m trying to get you to explain.
I’m gifted Mona Lisa, my net worth is now billion dollars. Am I hoarding billions in value?
I start a business and it becomes very succesful and it’s valued in billions and as a majority shareholder it makes my net worth now a billion dollars. Am I hoarding billions in value?I don’t understand who is keeping what away from everyone else. What is being hoarded exactly? What is “value” here?
I’ll assume you genuinely don’t grasp the concept, and not arguing in bad fath.
I start a business and it becomes very succesful and it’s valued in billions and as a majority shareholder it makes my net worth now a billion dollars. Am I hoarding billions in value?
If you are somehow 100% in charge in the production process of your business, and have no employees, and don’t meddle with politics, information distribution, pay your fair share of taxes, and (this is the important part) discovered a way to actually spend your billions in a way that actually reduces how much money you have so eventually you only have a couple millions, then no, you wouldn’t be hoarding wealth.
The reality is that all those things being true are extremely difficult and even more so rare - the only closest example I can think of in recent history being MacKenzie Scott.
Now, the reason the last point is important is because if you _don’t _ spend that money significantly, you actually start to contribute to inflation yourself because more money has to be printed so everyone else doesn’t run out, because otherwise you’d see economic collapse.
Except then comes the issue of spending billions - it’s extremely difficult to spend that money, _ without making more money._ A bit tongue and cheek, but to get an idea of how that would you can watch an old movie called “Brewster’s Millions” that’s a decent visual example. And in case you’re getting a little lost again, value = money. If you make more money despite spending it, you are, whether purposefully or not, hoarding it.
This leaves you with only 3 options to not hoard:
-
The government taxes the excess. This would also help control inflation. This hasn’t happened because of billionaires that want to hoard money. A recent example is the misinformation campaign in California.
-
Donating to charity. This is surprisingly difficult and takes years. See MacKenzie Scott.
-
Divvying up your value among all your workers. The easiest way to actually not hoard billions.
What is “value” here?
Here’s the most absurd part about it all - value is literally perception. It’s even worse under a fiat system because that valuation isn’t even tied down to something fixed and physical like with the gold standard, but can be tied to a commodity like oil.
The benefits are a country not rich in a certain resource can still generate a lot of value. But fiat still has many issues, like how easy it is to manipulate value. This leads to excessive inflation and way more economic bubbles and recessions.
So to recap; value = money = power. Value also = money^x when high and concentrated enough.
-
The relative amount of spending that rich people do to their net worth or whatever is much much smaller than the amount of spending middle class and poor people do.
If you think of a minimum wage worker who rents, nearly every dollar they make is back into the economy nearly immediately.
I on the other hand have maybe a third of my yearly income sitting in a high yield savings account.
Someone calculated that the amount that musk spent on the elections was the equivalent of a minimum wage worker spending like $30. He’s not doing that daily so he’s not using the equivalent amounts of money.
That is not what I asked about, though. The claim was that they’re hoarding money/wealth. This makes it sound like they have a lair full of chash somewhere like Scrooge McDuck.
Musk owns multiple succesful companies. His “wealth” is the value of these companies. You can’t buy a house by stating you own SpaceX, they want cash.
You can’t buy a house by stating you own SpaceX, they want cash.
Actually, you can say that SpaceX is worth x million dollars and offer it as collateral for a loan and because its an extremely large amount of collateral you’ll get an amazingly low interest rate and never have to use cash for anything. This is pretty much exactly how the Twitter purchase went down.
Semi-serious question, what if instead of inflation, there was a cap on how much money one person/entity could have? (Don’t ask me how we’d manage that though, just go with it)
It would encourage people to spend when they’re at or near the cap since they won’t be able to get any more. It would also discourage excessive saving for the same reason.
This was inspired by me wondering why Link can only have a certain amount of rupees at a time, depending on the size of his wallet
TLDR it up it seems to encourage consumption (good but only to a limit) and discourage lending your money to others to invest (bad).
There is no such thing as excessive savings. As long as you don’t have the money under the pillow but on a bank account or in bonds or stock the money goes back into the economy. You let others take a risk with your money and if they succeed you both get richer. Hopefully they took a risk to try to produce more stuff instead of day trading.
Does this cap include assets? (Eg stocks, bonds, property, machinery ). If it does you have to set it very high to allow whatever size company you deem is max to be viable. Then you don’t get many people spending or you don’t get any large scale operations. The reason food is cheap is because one guy with a huge expensive tractor owning a lot of land can grow a lot more than he eats. The reason you have a cheap phone is because there is a billion dollar factory making tens of thousands of the things.
If it does not then it’s stupidly easy to avoid it by buying assets that make money. This is why rich people get richer. They don’t have a lot of money, they have a lot of assets that make them money.
Are you allowed to deduct debt? You can’t borrow money to buy a tractor and land to grow food if you’re not.
The government can do all the large scale stuff but I’m old enough to remember which side of the Berlin wall the scratchmarks were on.
Deflation (opposite of inflation) encourages people to put money under the pillow and wait for it to increase in value. If everyone does this the economy stagnates.
I think this deserves a bit more discussion actually. I don’t think it’s a given that the economy stagnates nor that an ever-growing economy is a good thing.
At the end of the day, people must spend their money to get things they need. Hoarding money isn’t actually sustainable unless you already have more than you will ever need.
I actually think it sounds kind of nice to have an economy that is neither inflationary nor deflationary: it’s just stable because the economy is sized perfectly to sustain the people within it and make them happy.
It’s the insatiable greed that drives economic growth (at any costs it seems). I’m not sure whether population growth inherently grows the economy, because each new person is both an asset and a liability.
I think OP isn’t suggesting deflation, but equation. As in, keeping the value of a dollar stable rather than constantly changing. Like that Rick and Morty episode where there’s that machine that sets the value of $1 to $1
Not seen the episode so I’m not sure how it’s supposed to work.
A small inflation greases the wheels of the economy.
The central bank never hits the goal exactly, if you aimed for 0% you’d end up with sometimes inflation and sometimes deflation.
What is the value of one dollar anyway? When it was pegged to the gold the price of stuff compared to gold still varied.
In my mind, it’s not that inflation is good, but that deflation is far, far worse. The problem with deflation is your money buys more tomorrow than today, so you hold off spending it. Done en masse, that causes demand to drop. With people buying less, companies have to lower prices further, which means more deflation. It’s a self-perpetuating cycle.
Perhaps ideally we would be right on the knife’s edge between inflation and deflation, but we really do not have the ability to control the economy to that level of precision. The Fed can manipulate interest rates, print money, and that’s about it. Congress, if it wants to, can pull economic levers by raising and lowering taxing and spending. But these tools are not precision instruments, and they take months to reveal their effects.
If you try and aim for precisely 0% inflation, you’re likely to end up swinging between -1% and 1%. Which means you’ll be spending significant time in deflationary territory, risking a deflationary spiral. The Fed aims for a 2% inflation target. This gives them some buffer to hopefully keep us out of deflation.
I don’t understand why you call it worse, or even bad at all.
your money buys more tomorrow than today
This is evidently good.
you hold off spending it
Also good. Save money for retirement and emergencies.
Done en masse, that causes demand to drop
Less consumerism. Good again.
companies have to lower prices further
Still good. More acquisitive power for consumers, less money for CEOs, stockholders, and similar parasites.
More incentive to increase production efficiency and reduce waste, while proper regulations and actually punitive fines and civil and criminal responsibility for executives, board members, and stockholders keep salaries and quality up.
The concept of infinite growth has been raping and murdering the world for way too long. This looks like it would put a hard stop to it.
which means more deflation
So far so good?
It’s a self-perpetuating cycle
Sounds great, to be honest!
(Though, to be fair, prices would only keep lowering until goods are sold for what they actually cost to produce, including salaries and whatnot, with occasional drops due to increased efficiencies; the system would thus stabilise at an actually reasonable level, as opposed to the current ultraconsumerist madness.)
Think about your boss dropping your paycheck down to $200 a month (because money is so valuable now), but your rent is locked in at $1200 a month.
You need to think more communally.
Not wanting parasites to keep burning the world for short term profit is not thinking communally…?
That’s obviously not what I’m referring to. I ignored the environmental stuff as I don’t want to get off topic. Your points aren’t invalid, but they are off topic. Try to focus please.
Back to the actual economics we’re talking about. You’re thinking only about the money going into your pocket. You’re not thinking about the functioning of society as a whole. And you’re not looking more than two inches in front of your face. The deflationary cycle is also self-perpetuating because it also involves cutting demand for not just goods, but labor. Look at the Great Depression if you want to see what a deflationary spiral looks like.
What they should have said is that a system built on specific numbers going up to generate investment hype needs those numbers to keep going up and the easiest way to have the number go up is inflation.
Put aside all your personal feelings about money - how much you make, have, save, spend, or need. Money doesn’t mean anything, it is just a means of exchanging value so that someone who does plumbing for a living doesn’t have to also grow their own food and mine the metal to make the pipes.
A market economy is decentralized, there is no single decision-maker that mandates how many plumbers need to exist or how much pipe needs to be manufactured. Those decisions are made by market forces I.e. profit.
The information about how valuable something, someone, or some skill is in a decentralized system is determined through transaction. Money needs to flow in order to get accurate prices for everything and determine their value - valuable things have a market price that exceeds their costs to produce/maintain/etc. The greater the liquidity in a market (and the lower the cost to transact), the more accurate this information.
Inflation incentivizes spending money - on goods, services, or assets, rather than holding the currency itself. It can be thought of as a tax for withholding participation in the market. It increases liquidity and facilitates price discovery.
Broad deflation - the price of everything falling - is generally a sign of economic collapse. It means that no one wants what the economy is producing at the prices it can sustain… so stop making everything… food, houses, etc.
Sector deflation is quite common - electronics (until recently) got cheaper for decades - and this generally reflects increasing production efficiency and healthy marketplace competiton (good). But people spending less on TVs need to find somewhere else to spend that money to keep the system operating. Reducing spend overall is the signal to reduce output, which means recession, unemployment, etc. Economic contraction makes everyone poorer.
None of this would be bad if the life of the median person wasn’t balanced on a knife’s edge over the abyss of homelessness and poverty. Against that backdrop, it can often seem cruel that the system is designed in such a way that everything gets more expensive all the time. If your earnings aren’t keeping up with or exceeding inflation, however, it is the system telling you that the role is being culled. Find a new job (obviously easier said than done in most cases).
The first part is so textbook and academic (albeit undergrad level). The last paragraph is very different in tone.
Understanding how the machinery works is important, so is keeping empathy for the humans inside the machine.
Not an insult. Just a comment.
it forces people put their money into assets, which causes them to spend, that moves the economy
Let me add: I’m an engineer. By reason of existence, my work involves improving how we do stuff. My work involves helping people work more efficiently, use fewer resources, cost less etc. We should be doing more, with less because the tools and methods get better. So why do things keep getting more expensive? I don’t grok inflation. Not a bit of it.
Theoretically wages should be getting bigger to at least keep up with inflation (due to improving technology and the like they should be beating it), but in practice capitalist greed means it doesn’t always work that way.
The right way to look at how expensive things are is to normalize prices to other things that also change with time, for example wages and expectations.
A car may be more expensive now than in 1960, but the car is faster, safer, more comfortable, and more people have one now.
Same with many improvements- an iPhone today is more expensive than a Nokia 3210 was in 2000, but it has more features and more people have one.
It is against human nature to stay where we are and just use improvements to reduce the amount of work we need to do. We want to have more. That may be a bad thing for sustainability, but we typically expect our governments to support that kind of progress, hence the dual mandate of the central bank to maintain economic growth with a high level of employment and a low level of inflation.
It is against human nature to stay where we are and just use improvements to reduce the amount of work we need to do.
To be clear though since the industrial revolution and until WWII improving technology has both improved quality of life and reduced working hours. The fact that working hours have stagnated at around 40/week is a historical exception that doesn’t get fully or even mostly explained by “we have more and better stuff;” if that was it we should be working 20 hour weeks by now. For more see David Graeber on the subject.
There is a lot of inequality that plays into this.
If you think about 90s Goldman Sachs style of 80-100 hours weeks, no weekends, no holidays culture that dictated “work ethic” expectations in American white collar jobs, to the post covid hybrid work and “quiet quitting” culture: I think the typical white collar worker works way fewer hours than 20-30 years ago, even though contracts said 40 hours the whole time. Anecdotally, a cushy office job at individual contributor level can be apparently kept while working maybe 1-2 hours a day. I know those are not typical, but it’s way more common than it used to. And my perception is that taking weekends and holidays off became normalized, and nobody is virtue signaling anymore that they worked the whole weekend, even if they did. People take their vacations.Now that doesn’t mean the hours of hourly workers, healthcare workers, construction workers, service and restaurant industry workers, etc, are getting shorter, but as I said, that is more a social equality problem than anything about the economy or inflation rate specifically.
Okay you’re basically right that effective necessary (so discounting bullshit) white collar working hours are declining, but also you should really read the book I linked. It expands on what you said here on multiple levels, and I suspect you’ll find it somewhere between interesting and enlightening.
I’ll check it out!
But lots of things do get cheaper. You can buy a fucking miracle device like a smartphone for a weeks work. Everything you want gets cheaper, everything you need gets more expensive.
yes, because that’s how we have organized things.
we could make housing a commodity, but we have chosen not to do so. we have made it an investment. not every economy in the world works this way, or has, historically.
and generally we rampantly resist the idea of commodifying housing, education, healthcare, and other resources. but we’re OK doing it in other areas. these are largely political and social choices about what we perceive as having value and how that value should function and how those goods should be distributed.
Can of coke cost a penny. Now it’s closer to a buck?
I’m also an engineer, and in my experience a reduction of blue collar workers gives only a temporary reduction of the work force; soon enough there will be more cost controllers, HR business partners and officers for all kinds of non value adding stuff. In my country we’re at the point where the people with bizarre job descriptions on LinkedIn are always posting about how to effectively employ the work force.
right, and what if you think this book is bullshit itself?
this concept that some jobs are ‘real’ and others are ‘fake’ is just class-confirmation bias that has no basis in economic reality. Sure you might think a teacher deserves to make 250K because their job is ‘real’ and a investment banker doesn’t deserve 2.5million, but the truth is people generally value the investment banker far more than the teacher and the 1000x pay is reflective of that, especially as the teacher doesn’t help them increase their own wealth.
forced pretense and bullshit is how most of the world works, this idea some there is some perfect world where you don’t have to pretend to care about nonsense to advance your career is delusional, there is no such world.
So clearly you’ve not read the book, which I mean fair enough but then at least try to understand what the argument is before disagreeing with it based on dogma. Here’s how it defines a bullshit job:
Final Working Definition: a bullshit job is a form of paid employment that is so completely pointless, unnecessary, or pernicious that even the employee cannot justify its existence even though, as part of the conditions of employment, the employee feels obliged to pretend that this is not the case.
The idea being that the person actually doing the work is in the best position to tell if their work actually means something.
this concept that some jobs are ‘real’ and others are ‘fake’ is just class-confirmation bias that has no basis in economic reality.
Good assertion, I hope you’re ready to defend it against…
Gerte: In 2010 I worked as a receptionist at a Dutch publishing company. The phone rang maybe once a day, so I was given a couple of other tasks:
- Keep candy dish full of mints. (Mints were supplied by someone else at the company; I just had to take a handful out of a drawer next to the candy dish and put them in the candy dish.)
- Once a week, I would go to a conference room and wind a grandfather clock. (I found this task stressful, actually, because they told me that if I forgot or waited too long, all of the weights would fall, and I would be left with the onerous task of grandfather clock repair.)
- The task that took the most time was managing another receptionist’s Avon sales.
The book is full of exciting testimonies like this. Which is to say, the assumption that bullshit jobs don’t exist is clearly false.
but the truth is people generally value the investment banker far more than the teacher and the 1000x pay is reflective of that, especially as the teacher doesn’t help them increase their own wealth.
Investment bankers actually wouldn’t fit the definition in thr book anyway, but also hell no? Plenty of people want there to be more teachers in the world, or at least would consider that to ve a good thing out of hand. I struggle to think anyone ever thought the world needs more investment bankers. Besides, education is the best investment an average person can make by a long shot.
this idea some there is some perfect world where you don’t have to pretend to care about nonsense to advance your career is delusional
Just world fallacy. Just because something is normal doesn’t make it not bullshit, but also clearly a farmer or factory worker’s career doesn’t inherently involve pretending to care about nonsense. You should really read the book, if only to disagree with it in a more educated manner.
“other people’s jobs are bullshit, but not mine”
inherently contradicts “The idea being that the person actually doing the work is in the best position to tell if their work actually means something.”
The argument is bullshit itself. But this book isn’t trying to make a coherent argument, it’s trying to sell books by appearing to people’s resentment that their job is important and everyone else’s is stupid and worthless. Which pretty much everyone believes because we are all egotistically biased.
I don’t need to read the book. The ‘argument’ has been around forever in various forms. ‘bullshit’ jobs have always existed and will always exist, and are just a product of ignorance and idealism that the world would be ‘better’ without them. Everyone hates administrators and bureaucrats and support staff and thinks they shouldn’t have to exist and ‘get in the way’ of them doing ‘real work’.
You know what another bullshit job is? firefighting. last time I checked most firefighters aren’t putting out fires every hour of everyday they work…
You legitimately have no idea what you’re talking about and I’m starting you doubt you’re even reading my replies in full. Unless you’re willing to give me a point by point counterargument like a normal person, this conversation is over.
Yeah, I know. If you think this book is legit and insightful… well you might as well vote for Trump. You are a believer in nonsense. I bet you also think Trumps tariffs were ‘economic genius’.
You should read real books by economists if you want to understand the economy man. Not grandstanding anthropologists who think their bitterness is genius.
You have 2 questions:
- Why is a little bit of inflation desirable?
- But if the economy always needs injections of liquidity because otherwise it fails, isn’t the economy broken?
Most replies I saw dealt with only the first question.
First off - why some inflation is good: you got some good answers, but from what I saw, people talked about savings and debt but not consumption. Let’s say you’re thinking about buying a new TV. It costs $200, which you have, but you’re still on the fence. If you know that the next month the TV will cost $201, that just might be the push you need to buy it. But why does the economic system wants you to buy the TV now? Because everyone wants to get money sooner rather than later.
“Wait, so it’s just a scam to get my money?” Kinda, but not in a bad way. Money isn’t real, and you don’t gain anything by just owing money (investments are another thing). The sooner everyone gets your money, the sooner they’ll be able to use this money to do stuff, which will stimulate the economy. The same mechanism (albeit with some qualifiers) also increases your paycheck at the same rate, so the only way you lose out is if your money is just laying there doing nothing.
Now to the other part: “But if the economy always needs injections of liquidity because otherwise it fails, isn’t the economy broken?” Money isn’t real, man.
The system doesn’t really get “injected” with anything. What happens is that the government (well, central bank) prints out cash and gives it to banks as a loan. The banks are always happy to get money because they can use it to give out loans of their own. The government gets the money back with (a small) interest, so they’re also happy (and that’s why inflation is, in essence, a form of tax).
“Whoa there, the banks have to give the government the money BACK? so, at some point the banks have to get all of their money and give it to the government!? This is so much wore than I thought!” No no no, the banks repay the loan with MONEY not CASH.
“OK, Dude, you lost me” So, this is where it starts getting a bit complicated. Let’s say you have $200 in your checking account. The bank doesn’t actually have a $200 bill with you name on it. You want your $200 in cash? Sure, the bank will pull a $200 bill from its vault, but it’s not your personal $200 bill in the vault, and you probably don’t even want a $200 bill anyway (you’ll just pay the $200 with a credit card or whatever, and the bank will transfer the money digitally), so why bother? The bank just has to have enough cash to give to people who want it. The central bank sets a certain percent of cash that the banks must have against certain assets (ex. they must have 20% of the value of all checking accounts in cash). When the bank gets more cash, what it actually gets isn’t money, but permission from the government to loan out more money to people who want it.
The government loans cash to banks. The banks then give loans to other entities (companies/people) who want money now and can probably repay it later. This has the side effect of increasing both prices and wages while encouraging entities to use their money so that companies will want to keep making stuff they can sell. Win-win-win-win. Well, except people who have money just laying around not doing anything and having it decrease in value, they are the ones who are paying the inflation tax.
Bonus question: “Ah, so the reason we don’t want the inflation to get too high is so that the people paying the inflation tax won’t get taxed too much, otherwise the more inflation the more wins?” Nah, the people who pay the inflation tax are mostly poor, so screw 'em. Like with everything in economics, it’s a balancing act. High inflation takes away stability. In the beginning I said “you know that the next month the TV will cost $201”. But in reality, you don’t KNOW it, you assume some inflation. If people think inflation will be 2% and it’s actually 2.5%, that’s fine for the most part. But if they think it’ll be 200% and it’s 250%, that’s a difference of half the money people had at the start of the year, and is kinda a big deal. Also, the economic environment can’t react immediately to a price increase, and if the prices increase faster than the economy can react, it starts to break things and creates a feedback loop that increases inflation even more (which takes away MORE stability). This is called hyperinflation, and what economist consider An Extremely Bad Thing. An inflation of around 2% is considered the sweet spot for most modern economies. This is also the exact reason the central bank is the one in charge of printing money (and is actually the main reason there is such a thing as a central bank) - printing money is a very easy solution to governmental budgetary issues, but is also extremely dangerous for the economy as a whole. Just having the government a theoretical option to go there takes away financial stability from the system, so it’s much safer to have an independent professional institution to handle it.
Japan had deflation for 35 years, and keeps a mostly stable economy. Is inflation actually desirable? If you look at economics long enough it starts being about subjective politics, and systems people oversee and behave in. Somethings are true some times with certain goals, other things are true other times.
Inflation is more a byproduct of certain circumstances.
Japan had deflation for 35 years, and keeps a mostly stable economy. Is inflation actually desirable?
YES holly fuck Japan is NOT doing well. They seem to have survived but there are many structural problems caused by the “lost decades” -> economic stagnation.
…and even here it’s subjective. A 4.4 trillion dollar GDP (mostly driven by car companies, har har), a large role in globalized trade relations, less of a housing crisis than many places. A fairly thriving and unique culture and tourist industry.
They’re doing a lot better than many countries. So it all depends on what you think economics should do. Should it be about maximum profits and growth, or some other set of values ect… And that’s really difficult to pin down.
Personally I think it should ultimately serve the politics of the masses (eg. Be under democracy). Otherwise we’re all kind of slaves to it.
And their problems had nothing to do with deflation. They’re rampant consumerists and innovation chasers who just also happen to value conservative savings plans. They got outcompeted in the local area by cheap Chinese labor and their adoption of neoliberal economics did what it did everywhere else, sabotage their working class’s purchasing power even as they lost their foreign markets…
And they’re still the world’s fourth largest economy with the 12th largest and rapidly aging population.
Inflation, especially unexpected inflation, benefits debtors. The biggest debtors in the world are governments. It’s not zero sum. It creates winners and losers.
Sorry for the pedantry: zero sum means it creates winners and losers, because you can only give someone more by taking it away from someone else. “Not a zero sum” means you can create winners only, because you can generate value to give someone without taking it away from anyone else. Economy is never zero sum: a bad economy is bad for most, and a good economy is good for most. Cronies exploit poor people in both good and bad economic circumstances.
This is the best answer. At just 2% inflation, by the time you’re paying off that 30-year bond, it only costs 50%. Government can stay in perpetual debt, pumping money into the private economy, and inflation effectively pays off the debt.
yes, but this also assumes growth. you can have poor or no growth, and that introduce other problems with government debt.
and governments are not ‘debtors’ they hold debt, yes, but they can also manipulate the economy directly through politics and policy. your average person in debt, can’t do that.
another fatal mistake people make is thinking government debt, business debt, and personal debt, are all the same. they aren’t. they all have different rules and different mechanisms for how they are assessed and businesses can do things people can’t.
Google furry inflation
I prefer using e621 for this purposes
I do understand that it’s done to “stimulate” the economy so people don’t let their cash rot in a checking account, but isn’t it a zero-sum game?
The issue isn’t keeping money in a checking account, but under your mattress. Even in a checking account, your bank can still use a part of the money to create loans. Under your mattress, the money does nothing and that makes it more expensive for people who need money to pre-invest in something.
But if the economy always needs injections of liquidity because otherwise it fails, isn’t the economy broken?
Kind of, but requiring cash on hand with no lending at all breaks the economy a lot more. It forces all investment to occur to only people who have money and it makes running out of money a much easier thing to happen. If you read accounts of eras where money was much harder to be lent, you’ll see cash flow issues were much more significant even for large companies and corporations.
To add to this. In a lot of the developed world, you want to build a big resort, you make a business plan, you get investors, you secure a loan, and you build a big resort. In Mexico, it’s hard to secure those investors and cash flow, due in part to the uncertainty of the economy. So they build part of that big resort, say the first 10 floors of a 25 storey building. Then, as they get more money, they finish the building, then add more parts to the building. This is a limited example of what liquidity in the economy can mean - the ability to big things now rather than smaller steps over time.
To add onto your example, the Mexican company likely had the business plan to build out the 25 story building and fill it with guests immediately. Instead, they can’t. They also can’t build in as many amenities because they don’t have the number of guests to support it.
An American company can build the larger resort and fill it with guests immediately; making more money on day 1 even taking into account the interest they need to pay back. The Mexican company would find it much harder.
It’s pretty simple. Borrowed money by the government can be paid back with inflated (less valuable) dollars.
Except in cases where interest rates are near zero so the Govt goes on a massive borrowing binge for over a decade, doesn’t pay any of that debt back, after 10 or 20 years has to roll it over at the now current interest rates moving closer to 6%… Eventually you can’t really just keep borrowing more to pay back old debt, even with a reserve currency where $30 of the $40 trillion is domestic.
Rich people love when number go up
It’s desirable to the wealthiest, not the general population.
Edit: Some sources
https://360library.com/economics/deflation/common-misconceptions-about.html
This lists a couple of “recent” historical examples you can verify.
And here’s a more detailed analysis:
Inflation is, in fact, a way of making sure the economy isn’t a zero-sum game.
Musical chairs wouldn’t be much of a game if there were enough chairs for everybody. Oligarchs want everybody scrambling because it makes their pseudo-slavery easier to maintain.









