- cross-posted to:
- technology@lemmy.zip
- cross-posted to:
- technology@lemmy.zip
In early 2025, Atlanta resident Samuel Tunick was on his way home following a trip abroad. After landing in the US, customs agents demanded access to his Pixel phone, which was running an alternative version of Android called GrapheneOS. Rather than hand over his data, Tunick used a clever feature of the software to delete everything. Now, he’s facing federal charges.
The first hearing in this case happened last week, according to The Guardian, during which government attorneys and agents claimed that Tunick was subjected to a standard secondary interrogation at an international airport. During that encounter, agents were “looking for anything that’s prohibited.” However, Tunick’s legal team alleges he was targeted for his activism.
Tunick was involved with a group called Defend the Atlanta Forest, which opposed the construction of an enormous law enforcement training facility in the area often known as Cop City. What Tunick didn’t know, according to his lawyers, was that he’d been placed on a watch list for his actions and that Customs and Border Protection had discussed over email plans to detain him upon his arrival back in the US for “suspected terrorism activities.”



That is not a reliable solution. I cannot endorse this course of action at all. The bottom line is that it is nearly impossible to actually remove all sensitive data from a phone that was in active use. Also remember, deleting files is not the same as removing them from a computer, they’re still there if you know how to look. And having some of that data in the cloud makes you more vulnerable, not less. It means there’s a third party to get your data from and guess what, that party already has an existing relationship and agreement with law enforcement. And even if your data were safe in the cloud, just accessing it can leave that data sitting in caches on your device in locations you may not even be able to access (but law enforcement will).
Pretending that it’s possible to make a device safe is dangerous. Just take a burner.