• 0 Posts
  • 33 Comments
Joined 2年前
Cake day: 2025年2月6日
  • borokov@lemmy.worldtoSelfhosted@lemmy.world•[AI] Minimal expenses splitting softwareEnglish
    224·
    1か月前

    Hi dude,

    Well, “Here is my entirely generated LLM tool” is clearly a red flag. I’m a software engineer for 20 years, I’ll try to explain you why it is a redflag for developpers.

    • First, how many gallon of water and kg of coal were used to generate it ? Using LLM has a real hidden cost.

    • 3500 lines of code written in 1 week… Professional developers write around 10 to 100 lines a day. Why ? Because understanding a system takes time. Here, there are 3500 lines no one is able to explain. “It works” doesn’t mean “It works”. Building a software is not just about making it work in your own use case.

    • Github like platforms were created to collaborate. It is not possible to collaborate on a vibe coded application. There are too many code that were written too quickly. And without the whole prompt history, the model used, etc… it is not even possible to do “collaborative vibe coding”. Another agent with another prompt history won’t have the full context of application, and won’t be able to keep consistency.

    • Now, github, gitlab, codeberg, etc… are flooded by these kind of app, generate by a single person in a few days on which it is not possible to collaborate. OpenSource maintainer are flooded by AI Slope code, and more and more project are forced to become closed source, or to restrict contributions only to some user.

    • The developer of a software is the worst person ever to test it. There are cognitive bias that make the developer unconsciously avoid scenarios that can break the system. If only one developer built a product, I’m 100% sure I won’t be able to build and run it on my computer without trouble. And again, every vibe-coded application were built by a single person.

    If your tool works for you and your friend, cool. But the real value of a source code is not the source itself. It’s the people that worked on it, that built a common understanding, that ran it in several environment, with several use case, and that makes it robust. So don’t be mad if no one want to test your code.

  • borokov@lemmy.worldtoTechnology@lemmy.zip•Before We Blame AI For Suicide, We Should Admit How Little We Know About SuicideEnglish
    21·
    6か月前

    Interesting analysis indeed that make me review my position a bit.

    Where the article is right, is that we know very little about suicide, depression, and cognitive dysfunction in general. As it says, the only prevention method we currently have is basically asking “do you plan to kill yourself ?”. There are some protocol that can estimate the risk level like asking “have you ever consider it before”, “how many time in the last 2 weeks”, “have you ever thought about scenario”, “have you ever tried it”, etc… But some people may “simulate” suicide attempt dozen of time to ask for help, whereas other will kill themselves at first try without any prior sign.

    Lonely person may find refuge in LLM which may end up in a deadly trap. Like he could have ended up in MMO game, social networking or anything else that could lead to the same consequences. I just find too easy to blame AI because it’s a new way to lost itself. But where you are right, is that we could expect a human community to be naturally kind (most of the time…), whereas LLM doesn’t even understand the idea of kindness.

    Then, suicide and depression is not always due to social or environmental causes. Sometime, it’s cause by chemical unbalanced in brain. In that case, there is no psychological treatment and the only solution is medication (in current state of science).

  • borokov@lemmy.worldtoMemes@lemmy.ml•Don't Even Get Me Started On The Usefulness Of Learning How To Find The Area Of A Trapezoid
    11·
    1年前

    I’m pissed off by all the whiner complaining ScHoOl doEsn’t tEaCh aNytHiNg uSeFuL.

    You want to build a small hut in your garden, what dimension should be the carpentry ? How much concrete do you need ? How many tiles ? You are in top of your leader and need to put the roof at 17°, how do you do without protractor ?

    You have to put chemical in your pool, how to compute It’s volume ?

    You have to write a letter by hand for whatever administrative reason, how do you do ? Some administration do require hand written statement.

    You’re in a hotel where floors are numbered in roman, how do you go to your room ?

    You read a book, how do you know in which chapter your stoped ?

    You are in a real estate agency to buy a land. The land is trapezoidal and you notice the surface doesn’t correspond to what is written because those retard don’t know how to compute area of trapezoid (true story).

    And for god sake, life is not about just doing things that are useful ! Just watching the stars with your kid, and tell him “that is Mars and that is Jupiter”, doing quiz with friends and win a free beer, growing its own sodium Cristal in a glass, writing poesie, all of those are completely useless but are the best parts of life !!!