so, just walking through your own argument as I understand it: situations that are similar to the treatment of indigenous North Americans by the US can be considered imperialism, if it’s done by one nation to another nation. but the actual treatment of indigenous peoples by the US doesn’t meet that condition. the result of that syllogism must be: between the US and the indigenous peoples, one of them is not a nation. I assume you’re not saying that the US is not a nation. so the conclusion must be that the indigenous North American peoples were not a nation, or multiple nations; that there was no political or societal organization in the Americas before Europeans came. is that what you mean, or have I misunderstood?
arctanthrope
- 0 Posts
- 16 Comments
and my question is why do you think that’s not a form of imperialism
the “neighboring nation” I was referring to were the indigenous people. North America was not a blank slate before Europeans arrived. “manifest destiny” was imperialism
so you’re saying going to war against a neighboring nation to expand your territory is not what an empire does?
arctanthrope@lemmy.worldto
Political Discussion and Commentary@lemmy.world•Immigrants Not Learning The USA EnglishEnglish
121·14 days agoYes, I am only fluent in The USA English
no, you’re not
arctanthrope@lemmy.worldto
Today I Learned@lemmy.world•TIL over 40 000 people have used the social security number 078 05 1120 in the United States.English
23·25 days agoI guess when the consumers you’re targeting are apparently the type to need a demonstration of how a card fits in a wallet, you shouldn’t expect them to understand that that card is in fact solely for the purpose of that demonstration
what do you call it when you put the seed in the pot if not “planting”?
arctanthrope@lemmy.worldtomicromobility - Bikes, scooters, boards: Whatever floats your goat, this is micromobility@lemmy.world•MODS ARE SLEEPING, POST CYCLING WINEEnglish
8·1 month agobeer mixed with lemonade is called a Radler, which is German for bicyclist, so that’s also cycling beer (it’s also sometimes called shandy, idk what the difference is exactly, or if there even is one)
arctanthrope@lemmy.worldto
Automotive Industry@discuss.tchncs.de•Ford Recalled More Cars Than The Next 9 Brands Combined This YearEnglish
7·1 month agoI used to work for a company that supplied powertrain components for most major auto brands, all the guys who worked with Ford said they would never buy a Ford. maybe that’s just what happens when you see the sausage get made, but on the other hand I never heard the same from the guys who worked with other companies
arctanthrope@lemmy.worldto
Climate@slrpnk.net•Iceland has hottest Christmas Eve ever with temperature of 19.8C recorded101·1 month agoroughly 68°F btw
arctanthrope@lemmy.worldto
News@lemmy.world•A Million More Epstein Documents Have Been Found, Justice Dept. Says
16·1 month agoa million documents is on average about one document every 35 minutes for his entire life. that seems like a lot, even for a broad definition of “document”
live SpongeBob reaction
arctanthrope@lemmy.worldto
Technology@lemmy.world•This long-term data storage will last 14 billion yearsEnglish
56·2 months agothis isn’t new, “making smaller marks on a rock” has been mankind’s method for expanding data storage for thousands of years
edit - hmm, needs workshopping I guess. maybe something like: “over thousands of years, humans have refined data storage from its most primitive beginnings as marks on rocks, to its most advanced novelty, different marks on different rocks”
exactly, the real Luddites weren’t opposed to technology, they were opposed to wealthy factory owners using technology in a way that eliminated or cheapened their labor to extract more profit. what Sanders and most others are citing as threats posed by “ai” are actually perfectly in line with the Luddites, but they’re not allowed to say so because the actual history of the Luddites has been smeared and propagandized to make them look like unreasonable morons who are scared of things they can’t comprehend
arctanthrope@lemmy.worldto
Science@mander.xyz•Tattoo Ink Moves Through the Body, Killing Immune Cells and Weakening Vaccine Response
91·2 months agowould it be possible to solve this problem by making different inks? or would any ink that doesn’t have this problem just inherently be non-permanent


ok I see. my understanding of imperialism is that it encompasses both of those, meaning broadly, expansion of influence, especially (but not necessarily) by claiming areas of land, in order to gain control of resources currently held by others. but I agree, there are two types within that, and the distinction between them is whether the people currently occupying the land (or in particular their labor) are part of the resources that the empire is trying to claim