Yeah but it’s not solved JFC.

Of course it isn’t solved. Because Reddit does not want to solve it. It doesn’t want users to know how large the community of a subreddit is. It’s simply cooking the numbers: the bigger the better, even if bigger = less accurate. So it’s replacing an inaccurate metric with an even more inaccurate metric.

And, again: it didn’t even need to replace it. I’m saying it should show both metrics dammit. Both are inaccurate, but with both you have better grounds to reach less inaccurate conclusions about community size than with only one of them.

And this is bloody obvious. Specially from Lemmy:

Could could could isn’t accomplished by their currently showing subscribers of dead accounts. JFC.

The fact it could but it won’t matters here, even if you pretend otherwise.

And it couldn’t be solved easily anyway. What’s a dead account? Log in once a year? That’s certainly not active in that community. But hey let’s count that anyway, right? Subscribed but all you do is browse all? Not active, but let’s count that too, right? A game is popular for a while and gets tons of subscribers, then peters off and the people don’t unsub and just browse all. Again: not active, but fuck it let’s count that too. See the problem yet?

“Unless you can solve it perfectly right off the bat than its impassible!!! lol lmao”

Start with an arbitrary cut-off line for activity. Then tweak it over time. Done.

Enjoy the last word if you want it.

I don’t care about the last word. But I do care someone is vomiting false dichotomy, eating their own vomit, and expecting me to eat it alongside them. I’m not doing it.