Etsy changed its terms of use, adding a clause on AI training. Now, it has clarified that it will not use sellers’ content to train AI that can copy their work.
Mayhem Marketplace…fuck Etsy
This is so frustrating. I reopened my Etsy shop in April after a long hiatus and have worked very hard to gain new customers and put my items out there and then they pull this crap. I would like to move my shop to my own website or another platform but I feel like I don’t have the exposure and customer recognition yet. It’s a crappy situation for true handmade sellers and just sucks all around
Speaking of, is the platform getting borderline unusable to anyone else? There was always a bunch of low effort resells but now I can barely discover anything on the platform itself without wading through seemingly pages of slop art.
Did someone sell a course on become independently wealthy by tricking people again?
I’m just glad I haven’t seen that one weird ad in a while!
Translation: they will do that, but not tell anyone about it.
Ah, The Google/Facebook/Microsoft strategy I see.
Until the fines and ramifications outweigh the profits, they won’t stop. They’ll just apologize later. I guarantee it.
Typical tech bro attitude: Yeah, but when the chickens come home to roost, I won’t be working here.
Money today, please!
I’m sorry, but the social contract has been broken for a long time, and there is no assumed level of mutual respect or consent. Without evidence to the contrary, with any walk back we should assume that they’re going to do it anyway without your permission and more quietly.
I don’t buy that, this is just like Google walking back WEI or like MS walking back Recall, they’re just sorry they got caught and will just try again later after the heat dies down.
If you’re a crafter or a maker of any kind, you’ll be better off selling your stuff at a local farmer’s market or a street festival, or finding some community-ran online marketplace (no, FB Marketplace doesn’t count), or even selling on your own website if you have your own website, than taking a losing gamble with Etsy or even eBay for that matter.
Okay but their word means less than nothing until they put it in clear writing in the policy.
Does that even mean anything? Until we aggressively punish unethical business practices, the beatings will continue.
Once they’ve already sold our data, what are we going to do about it?
Yeah there need to be actual inquiries as to who was present at the meetings where this was decided and who pushed for it or approved it. If they have a legal department or finance department, did they know about this? Did they crunch the numbers on whether this was a worthwhile risk? Did they have misgivings they didn’t share? Lead engineers who implemented this without pushback?
Get the lower rungs, the lieutenants if you will, to roll over on the higher ups and watch consumer rights suddenly get mysteriously so much better all over the world.
I feel like I’m stating the incredibly obvious, but:
These agreements are contracts, breaches result in legal actions including class action and state originated lawsuits. This happens all the time. Last week Facebook was ordered to pay almost a billion dollars for improperly browsing user’s photos.
At this point I don’t think it’s enough to fine the corporate person. There need to consequences for the people in power knowingly making these unethical decisions.
In case of chemical spills or loss of life I would agree but idk if making a copy of a persons photos when they grant you access to their library is necessarily a criminal offence.
Either way, these institutions operate for profit, so the fines should be enough if they’re large enough and enforceable. A company with too many will just shut down on its own.
You showed us who you were. We believe you. We won’t let you mask back up.
Last I checked etsy is basically ebay + aliexpress, there’s no handcrafted artisan shops anymore
There are but you have to look real hard for them.
Source: me who has a handmade artisan shop on Etsy thay utilizes no AI in anything I make and sell
They got run over by Etsy’s practices and allowing copycat shops to exist (AI or not).
I saw one owner who was talking about how she had been in business for years, started noticing shops that had a variation of her product with slight changes, using her same advertising layouts, and when she filed a complaint, HER shop got banned.
The concept of Etsy is great, they ruined it.
Yet another piece of shit tech company.
What’s the new artisan shoppe? I used to love Etsy, but it’s been garbage for a very long time now.
Remember where you saw it? I’d love to read more.
It was a Youtube, probably short. She made quilted carriers for I think a chicken? Sounds weird, but she had a good business, and then she didn’t.
Which is such a shame. I used to use it back when it was a barely funtional site, and a bunch of the creators had a pay it forward system for supplies they no longer wanted or needed. That helped so much with my crafting! I even adapted the things I made to use the freebies I got from pay it forward! And gave away the result half the time just for funsies!
Half of my sales back then (I was a teen) were to people I was actively talking to in chat, which I think probably no longer exists. I’d share the thing I made and they’d love it enough to make me create a post to buy it, so the platform got a cut. Like the monkey hat I made that was too small and ended up child size, bought by my yarn seller, froggy fibers! They sent me all sorts of promotopnal materials back then, toys and samples and stuff.
It was a great community, back around 2000.
Its still quite small but, mayhem marketplace feels like old school etsy.
no thanks.
this was the final straw. before this fuck-up you guys allowed cheap Chinese knockoff weibo bullshit to be sold as "hand crafted’ product.
I went there on a whim to get a type of tshirt. So fucking AI slop that I just noped out. Pages and pages of slop everywhere. I hope their market crumbles.
I saw drink tumblers with AI-generated disney wraps. Etsy should die.
Too late. When they show you who they are, believe them the first time & run tf away
Apply universally, the old adage never fails
Trust is lost already. How can we believe them now?
A blog post saying they won’t do it, but they don’t update the terms to remove the language saying they are going to. I’ll be ignoring this blog post until they change the terms.
Boy, the corps really only see one thing. Groupthink all the way to the “top”. So fucking gross.












