I get what you’re saying about the one in a million, one in a billion, doesn’t matter still try, but specifically in this case I would think you’re far more likely going to make her tense up which is a bad thing for falls and high intensity impacts.

So in this instance you’ve got a nine out of ten chance of making things worse, and a one in a million chance of making things better.

I still agree always try to help no matter how small the chance, but I don’t think yelling about the rope is gonna help anyone here.